Jun 10 2008

a grade by any other name would still stink

Published by Lucia at 2:04 pm under grading

The concept of grading student work is one with which I continue to struggle. I’ve been reproached, by parents, students and administrators, for not having enough graded assignments during a grading period. How exactly am I supposed to define “enough”. My students claim they deserve a grade for everything they do. Parents, the ones who actually look at my grade book, generally expect daily grade posts. I’ve had administrators suggest that I post at least one test grade and one assignment grade per week. My question is always: Why should I assign a grade to student work when what most of my students need is relevant feedback that leads to a higher level of understanding and mastery of the concept being learned? I’m waiting for an answer I can swallow without choking.

Clay Burell’s post brought the grading enigma back to the forefront of my post-school year reflective mind. I’m still ingesting the post. He’s given me much to feed upon.

I’m not happy with how I served up grades this year. My attempts to make my grades meaningful ended in failure; I accomplished nothing more than to feed the machine. Mind now, no one complained about or questioned my grading system. That knowledge does nothing to placate my discontent.

I imagine that there are teachers who have solved this conundrum.

Alas, my thoughts are beginning to dissolve into random chaos. A clear signal that I need to stop thinking on this until my thoughts regain some sense of order.

Share/Save/Bookmark

Sphere: Related Content

3 Responses to “a grade by any other name would still stink”

  1. Clay Burellon 10 Jun 2008 at 5:50 pm

    First, what a great “About” page. I’m glad you added it, since I looked yesterday and you hadn’t done so yet. :)

    Re: assessment, Adrienne Michetti seems to have much to offer in this respect.

    Wish I had time for more, but have to run to work. I’ll just say thanks for the kind words and know that, clearly, you’re not alone when it comes to assessment and grading. My own case was the opposite: I had about 50 grades for semester 2, and felt no better about what that meant.

    Clay

  2. Luciaon 11 Jun 2008 at 5:10 am

    It is good to know that I’m not alone. I’ll spend some time on Adrienne Michetti’s site.

  3. [...] Lucias last blog post..a grade by any other name would still stink [...]

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply